What a Texas Shooting or Stabbing Victim Can Recover: Uncapped Compensatory Damages, Limits on Punitive Awards, and How the State's Crime Victims' Compensation Program Fits In

Texas does not cap ordinary compensatory damages, but punitive awards are limited. How civil claims work with the Attorney General's victim compensation fund.

What a Texas Shooting or Stabbing Victim Can Recover: Uncapped Compensatory Damages, Limits on Punitive Awards, and How the State's Crime Victims' Compensation Program Fits In

The cost of surviving a shooting or stabbing in Texas can be staggering. A single trauma admission may run into six figures. Return trips to the operating room, rehab sessions, therapy appointments, and long stretches without a paycheck pile on fast. After a deadly attack, a household's money troubles land on top of grief no dollar amount can describe.

Two separate sources may help: a civil negligent-security claim against the property owner, and the state's Crime Victims' Compensation program. They work differently and can complement each other.

Compensatory damages in a civil claim

For ordinary negligence, Texas statutes put no general ceiling on what jurors may award to make a victim whole. Those losses typically include:

  • Hospital bills already paid and treatment still to come, from operations to counseling
  • Lost wages and reduced capacity to earn in the future
  • Physical pain and mental anguish
  • Disfigurement and physical impairment

One technical rule affects medical bills. Under a provision known as Section 41.0105, recovery of medical expenses is limited to amounts actually paid or incurred by or on behalf of the injured person, rather than the higher sticker price a hospital may list.

Wrongful-death and survival damages

When an attack is fatal, spouses, children, and parents may recover for lost financial support, lost care and counsel, loss of companionship and society, mental anguish, and lost inheritance. The estate, through a survival claim, may recover the deceased person's medical costs, conscious pain before death, and funeral and burial expenses.

Exemplary damages are limited

Texas permits exemplary, or punitive, damages only when the plaintiff proves fraud, malice, or gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence, and the jury's decision on that question must be unanimous. Even then, Chapter 41 generally caps the award at the greater of $200,000 or twice the economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000. Gross negligence in a security case might involve an owner who knew of an extreme risk, such as repeated shootings on the premises, and consciously chose to do nothing.

Reductions for shared fault

If the jury assigns the injured person part of the responsibility, Texas reduces the award by that percentage. Anyone pegged at above half the responsibility walks away with nothing. The jury may also assign a share to the attacker, which can affect how much the property owner ultimately pays.

The Crime Victims' Compensation program

The Office of the Attorney General of Texas runs a Crime Victims' Compensation program funded largely by court costs paid by convicted offenders. It can help eligible victims and families with expenses such as medical bills, counseling, lost wages, and funeral costs. For crimes occurring after September 1, 1997, the general maximum is $50,000, and additional funds may be available in certain catastrophic-injury cases.

Compensation is generally a payer of last resort, available after insurance and other sources are used. Applicants must meet eligibility requirements, including cooperating with law enforcement. The program's application line is 1-800-983-9933.

How the two sources interact

Applying for state compensation does not prevent a civil lawsuit. But if a victim later recovers money from the property owner, the program may be entitled to reimbursement for benefits it paid. Coordinating both tracks from the start helps avoid surprises and keeps the family's net recovery in view.

Documenting losses from day one

Save statements from providers and insurers, wage records, and mileage logs for medical visits. A simple journal describing pain, sleep problems, missed events, and emotional struggles can help a jury understand losses that do not appear on paper.

When insurance and liens enter the picture

Health insurers, Medicaid, Medicare, and hospitals may assert liens or reimbursement claims against a settlement or verdict. Texas has specific hospital-lien rules, and federal programs have their own repayment requirements. Identifying those claims early, and negotiating them where possible, can make a significant difference in how much a victim actually takes home.

Deadlines

A two-year limit typically applies to injury suits, starting at the attack, and to death claims, starting when the person died. Claims against government entities may require notice within six months, and city charters can shorten that further.

About the firm

Haggard Law Firm attorneys in Coral Gables have tried and resolved nearly 500 negligent-security matters around the country; their courtroom record includes $102.7 million returned by one jury, which the firm calls the top award in U.S. negligent-security history, stated here as a gross figure. Michael A. Haggard is admitted only in Florida. Each Texas file is shared with a lawyer admitted to practice in Texas, and where rules allow Mr. Haggard may petition the judge for pro hac vice status limited to that dispute. Texas counsel is involved from start to finish.

Lawyers' fees come only out of money recovered; the signed fee contract spells out the treatment of litigation expenses. For a private, cost-free review, phone (305) 446-5700. For more information, visit: https://crimevictim.attorney/negligent-security/texas/

Attorney advertising. Damage rules and program limits are summarized for general information and may change; consult a Texas-licensed attorney about your situation. Contacting the firm does not on that basis alone establish representation. Michael A. Haggard is a Florida lawyer without Texas licensure. No prior verdict ensures a particular result.

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *