Once the shock of an attack begins to fade, practical questions take over. How long is there to act? Will the owner pay everything, or only part? Can the law limit the size of a verdict? Arizona answers each of those questions in its own way, and the answers can change strategy in a Tucson negligent-security case from the first week.
The basic limitations period
A.R.S. § 12-542 sets a two-year limit for most personal-injury claims in Arizona, including those against private property owners for inadequate security. The same two-year period generally applies when a family brings a wrongful-death action under the state's wrongful-death statutes, measured from the date of death.
A few situations can alter the timeline. When the injured person is a minor, the period is usually paused until the child turns eighteen. Claims against a government body follow a much shorter track: written notice served within 180 days per A.R.S. § 12-821.01 and a lawsuit within one year. Because exceptions are narrow and fact-specific, nobody should count on one without legal advice.
Where Tucson cases are heard
Most Tucson negligent-security lawsuits go to the Superior Court of Arizona in and for Pima County, located downtown. If the parties are from different states and the amount in dispute is large enough, a defendant may try to move the case to the federal court in Tucson. Each forum has its own procedures, scheduling, and jury pool.
Pure comparative fault for the victim
A.R.S. § 12-2505 adopts what lawyers call pure comparative fault. An injured person who is found partly responsible for what happened, for example by walking through a lot the person knew was dangerous, still recovers, with the award cut by the percentage assigned to the person. Even a majority share of fault does not wipe out the claim.
Fault can also be assigned to the attacker
This is the rule that often surprises people. Arizona has largely replaced joint and several liability with several-only liability under A.R.S. § 12-2506. In practice, jurors may spread percentages across every party whose conduct played a part, which can include the person who fired the shot or swung the knife. Each defendant then generally pays only its own share.
That makes the allocation fight central in a Tucson security case. Plaintiffs typically present evidence showing how the property's failures created the opportunity for the crime and why the owner's responsibility is substantial. Expert testimony on industry security practices, along with the property's own records, often carries much of that weight.
A brief example of how allocation works
Imagine a jury awards a total of $1 million and assigns 60 percent of the fault to an apartment owner who ignored a broken gate, 30 percent to the unidentified gunman, and 10 percent to the injured tenant. Under several liability, the owner would generally owe $600,000. The share assigned to the gunman is typically uncollectible, which is why evidence about the owner's role matters so much. Real cases are more complicated, but the illustration shows the stakes.
No legislative limits on damages
The Arizona Constitution, in Article 2, Section 31, forbids any law limiting the amount of damages recoverable for death or personal injury. A related provision preserves the right to sue for injuries. Together, these mean a jury may award what the evidence supports for:
- Emergency care, surgery, rehabilitation, and future treatment
- Past and future lost earnings and diminished earning ability
- Pain, suffering, disfigurement, and emotional distress
- In wrongful-death claims, the losses suffered by surviving family members
Punitive damages are a separate matter with a demanding standard of proof and are available only in limited circumstances.
Protecting the claim in the first weeks
Practical steps support every rule above, and most of them cost nothing but attention. Keep medical records and bills organized, document missed work, and preserve photos of the location. Avoid public posts about the incident. Ask counsel to send prompt preservation letters so video, guard reports, and maintenance data are not lost before suit is filed.
About the firm and its Arizona arrangements
Approximately 500 negligent-security files from around the nation sit in the case history of the Haggard firm's Coral Gables lawyers, who also earned a $102.7 million verdict the firm identifies as the largest such award in American history; the figure is gross. Florida issued Michael A. Haggard his license to practice; Arizona never has. Any Tucson case proceeds with an attorney licensed in Arizona as co-counsel; if Mr. Haggard is to appear before a Pima County judge, the court would first need to approve his pro hac vice application covering this one matter. The Arizona lawyer handles the matter jointly from beginning to end.
There is no attorney fee without a recovery. For a private discussion that carries no charge, the office line is (305) 446-5700.
Attorney advertising. Statutes and constitutional provisions are summarized here for general understanding only; specific advice requires review of your facts, and a phone call or web form is not a retainer. Mr. Haggard carries a Florida license but holds no Arizona one. A record verdict in one case cannot assure success in any other.








